15% OFF for new customers (enter code WELCOME15 at checkout) + Enjoy free shipping on all cookie & pretzel orders over $50
Contact Us

Cart 0

Sorry, looks like we don't have enough of this product.

Pair with
Is this a gift?
Add order notes
Subtotal Free
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

Products

Filters

Candy Shop Cookies
Seasonal
Packaged Amount
Availability
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
View 40 items
 

Berry Odee Oats

Cranberry Oatmeal Cookie
Restocking Soon
 

Berry Odee Oats

Cranberry Oatmeal Cookie
Restocking Soon
 

Bestsellers Collection

Circus Peanut, First Stop Fishpaws, Lemon Key
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 

Bubbly

Champagne Cookie
Restocking Soon
 

Caramelized Onion & Thyme Focaccia

$28.00 • 2 Loaves
 

Casanova Crunch

Sweet Heat Pretzels with Bourbon
$30.00 • 3 Packages
 
Dairy & Gluten-Free

Circus Peanut

Peanut Butter Cookies
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 

Citrus Collection

Grapefruit Crush, Lime Key, Lemon Key, Orange Key
Restocking Soon
 

Derby Crunch

Pretzels with Chocolate, Pecans & Bourbon
$30.00 • 3 Packages
 

First Stop Fishpaws

Vanilla Bourbon Traditional Chocolate Chip Cookies
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 

Grapefruit Crush

Grapefruit Cookies with Real Juice & Zest
Restocking Soon
 

Hail Raisers

Monster Cookie with Peanut Butter, Oats & Chocolate Candies
Restocking Soon
 

Holiday Collection

Mynthē, Ma Chérie, Berry Odee Oats
Restocking Soon
 

Le Choco

Chocolate Chip Cookies with Pecans
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 

Lemon Key

Lemon Cookies with Real Lemon Juice & Zest
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 
Available Mar to Aug

Lime Key

Lime Cookies with Real Lime Juice & Zest
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 

Ma Chérie

Decadent Vanilla Cookie with Candied Cherry
Restocking Soon
 

Ma Chérie

Decadent Vanilla Cookie with Candied Cherry
Restocking Soon
 
Available Mar to Aug

Meet Me in Watch Hill

Almond Cookie
$30.00 • 3 Packages of 6 Cookies
 

Mini Caramelized Onion & Thyme Focaccia

$28.00 • 4 Mini Loaves
 

Mini Rosemary Focaccia

$26.00 • 4 Mini Loaves
VanEllin Two Mini Onion & Sage Focaccia
 
VanEllin Two Mini Onion & Sage Focaccia

Mini Sage & Onion Focaccia

$28.00 • 4 Mini Loaves
 

Mini Sea Salt Focaccia

$26.00 • 4 Mini Loaves
 

Mini Tomato & Olive Focaccia

$28.00 • 4 Mini Loaves